The body of So You Are, a five-year-old racehorse that finished eighth in this year's Melbourne Cup, was found in a large metal skip bin surrounded by household rubbish in Sydney. The image is hard to look at, and it should be. A horse that had won four times this spring, including at Rosehill, Randwick and the Bendigo Cup, ended up in a place no animal of that standing should go.
Racing NSW, the state's industry regulator, said a preliminary investigation found the horse was later properly buried. That finding does little to settle the matter. The regulator also called the handling of the remains "completely unacceptable", and that judgement is the right one. The regulator itself said burial should have happened "in a timely and respectful manner". Whatever the paperwork later shows, the body was sitting among rubbish while it waited.
The trainer, Bjorn Baker, said he was "deeply distressed" and called for a "full explanation". He is right to ask for one. The hospital where the horse died, REC Equine Specialists, said it chose the disposal provider and "take full responsibility". That is the correct place for responsibility to sit, and it should not stop at an apology. A hospital that picks a contractor is answerable for how that contractor treats the animal in its care.
The company says it has stopped using the contractor and is reviewing its processes. Those steps are necessary but not sufficient. Owners who pay for care at a specialist facility are entitled to know, in writing, what happens to a horse once it leaves that building, who handles it and where it goes. Racing NSW should require that chain of custody be documented and inspected, not left to private assurances.
The footage was filmed by builder Gregg Jowett at what appeared to be the Lucas Heights public drop-off and landfill in Sutherland Shire. The waste operator said the body had been moved to a skip bin in a permitted area. Permitted is a technical word. It does not answer the question that matters to the people who loved this horse: why was an animal of this profile placed among household waste at all?