Reddit and a digital rights group told Australia's High Court on Tuesday that the country's under-16 social media ban is unconstitutional and should be struck down. Reddit's lawyer, Perry Herzfeld, argued the law breaches the implied freedom of political expression in the constitution by cutting children off from what he called the most important means of communication in the modern world.
Herzfeld said the ban was "ill thought out," contradicted the advice of Australia's online safety tsar, and was rushed through without true public consultation. He noted that the public had only 24 hours to make submissions.
The constitutional challenge was filed by the Digital Freedom Project, led by New South Wales parliamentarian John Ruddick, before the ban took effect on 10 December last year. Ruddick told reporters outside the court that the policy amounts to "censorship."
Two teenagers who originally backed the case, Noah Jones and Macy Neyland, have withdrawn as plaintiffs. They have not publicly stated their reasons. Jones attended the hearing and said children "deserve to have their voices heard."
Communications Minister Anika Wells said outside the court that the government would defend the ban. She described the question of what society will accept from tech platforms as "the most compelling policy question of our time." Government lawyer Joanna Davidson SC began outlining why the government believes social media harms children, and she will continue on Wednesday.
Under the law, ten platforms must take "reasonable steps" to stop users under 16 from accessing their services. The platforms are Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Reddit, Snapchat, X, Kick, Threads and Twitch. Platforms face fines of up to A$99m (US$70m, £52m) for serious or repeated breaches. The eSafety Commissioner has launched several investigations into alleged non-compliance by Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, TikTok and YouTube, but no company has been fined so far.
Reddit said it shares the goal of protecting young people online "but there are better and more effective ways" than a ban. Its chief communications officer, Adam Collins, said the company will keep complying with the law while it challenges it in court.