Smallholder farmers in Tanzania's Dodoma region say they have not benefited from digital agriculture services because they lack training and receive information too late, according to a report by Al Jazeera.
Theresia Abel Nyoka of Paranga village has received messages about M-Kilimo and e-Kilimo but has never registered. "It is simply because we have not been given education. I do not know their importance or benefits," she told Al Jazeera.
M-Kilimo is a Ministry of Agriculture mobile service that provides market information and farming advice. Jeremiah Luwe, a maize and pigeon pea farmer in Ngomai village, said responses to his questions can take up to two weeks. "Sometimes the information arrives too late to be useful," he said.
Adam Rashidi of Kingale village said, "If I am given education, I can register." Shaban Omary, who has no smartphone, said, "If I knew how to use it, it would help me."
The government is funding the $3.62 million Data for Digital Agricultural Transformation Joint Programme, which runs from September 2024 to August 2027. Its targets include improving digital literacy for 500,000 farmers and training 500 government extension workers. The Ministry of Agriculture did not respond to requests for comment.
A 2024 study cited by Al Jazeera reported about 7.2 million registered farmers on M-Kilimo and 75,623 advisory consultations, of which 73,839 received replies. The study said these figures do not show how many farmers actively used the service or whether it improved their decisions. It also found about 400,000 incomplete registrations and difficulties with the USSD service. No comparable figures have been published for e-Kilimo.
Praygod Malisa, an agriculture specialist with Rikolto East Africa in Tanzania, said training, phones, SIM cards, connectivity and cost are barriers. "If farmers do not know the technology, it has no benefit for them," he said.